Although history doesn’t repeat itself, as two moments will never be exactly the same, it does rhyme because of the common tendencies that humans share. Yes, events from the past do have similarities to the present, even if they aren’t identical because human behavior and specific social patterns are bound to reoccur. According to Theodor Reik, “ There are recurring cycles, ups and downs, but the course of events is essentially the same, with small variations. It has been said that history repeats itself. This is perhaps not quite correct; it merely rhymes”. I completely agree with his opinions because events are unique to their own selves to a certain extent. For example, some events are tied to specific time periods or conditions to that time, such as the American Revolution, would never repeat in the United States, one reason being there’s more than 13 colonies here now, and the U.S. is under the control of Great Britain anymore. Events are repeated, but may emerge in a different form. Specifically within the Weimar Republic, the hyperinflation period rhymes with today's inflation as prices are drastically rising , despite the Republic being on a much larger scale that the U.S has never matched. The Americans who ran and crowded the stores for toilet paper and stealing baby powder during the early stages of Covid, resemble the Germans who crowded the streets of Berlin to obtain low-stock demanded items, as well as an uprising in robberies and looting. On the other hand, Anti-Semitism is widely seen in current events, as the war between Palestine has heightened both Anti-Semitism and Islamophobia, specifically there have been cases on Anti-Semitism that have been captured on the news in the U.S, such as stabbing Jewish officials, shootings, hate-speech/slurs, or vandalism.
Political chaos echoes in both the Weimar Republic and in the United States, as the abdication of Wilhelm II left the Germans without the monarchy, whereas the government shutdown was temporary but definitely caused a lot of problems. Both, very different, events raised uncertainty, lack of faith for the government, showcased the instability, and growing tensions that heightened racism and prejudices amongst different people. Conversely, Jews were a means for scapegoating in the republic, just as many minority groups today are blamed for certain things that are going on in life today, including but not limited to Jews. According to Julia and Lidia, “ The Weimar Republic then started to be recognized as the “Jew Republic”, further emphasizing how Germans thought that Jewish people were the cause of all their post WWI issues”. Again, when conditions aren’t optimal, there needs to be someone to take the fall for these subpar conditions, most likely it’s the minorities, or groups that are already not well-liked. However, according to another point that was made in their project, Julia and Lidia said that “ ‘The Agitator’, By George Grosz the jumbled figures, distorted shames. And crowded space represents how the German people felt in a society full of propaganda and rapid change.” This echoes in today’s society with the rising influence of social media. Social media not only promotes propaganda, but is propaganda to me. I don’t mean in the sense of lying or promoting lies, but in the way that they are both devices that are wired to communicate or sway people towards a specific objective/goal. They both either make people think one way, or a way that is starkly different.
On the contrary, with the Anti-Semitism occurring, it creates an us. vs. them mentality, which plays on the idea that in the Weimar Republic people were allotted the right to treat Jews badly because they are the “them”, or the reason for all the failures. Furthermore, with the prevalence of this prejudice, a lot of people tapped into the idea of mob mentality, “since a lot of people are acting this way in a large group, why would I not do the same?” It also plays on the idea of a charismatic leader, such as Hitler, as well as obedience theory. How far are Germans willing to take this? With growing resentments towards the unstable government, extremist groups, such as the Nazi Party, exploited the attraction felt by people who were desperate to be a part of something much stronger and more put together. Unfortunately, it also makes me think of the Armenian Genocide for the reason that the Young Turks sought for reforms and a better sense of government that couldn’t be achieved with Christian Armenians present, therefore they sought to exterminate or rid them to achieve what they wanted. Lastly, the Weimar Republic was met with deep political tensions and divisions, which rhymes with today's political parties, radical left or radical right. If you are a liberal, who is deeply political and passionate, you’re more than likely to view a conservative as an enemy, or binding their personality to their politics, and vice versa if you are a conservative. People are being reduced down to a label that represents their political party, which is fact is telling, but then also ignorant because for a lot of people, their personalities boil down to something much more than their political beliefs.